
Key points
- A dispatcher acting as a bona fide agent of a motor carrier, under a preexisting agreement and the carrier's direction, does not need FMCSA broker authority.
- No single factor decides it. FMCSA says the greater the carrier's control, the less likely the dispatch service needs broker authority.
- "Allocating traffic" means any discretion in assigning a load to a carrier. A dispatcher representing several carriers who does this is not a bona fide agent.
- Brokers need a $75,000 surety bond (Form BMC-84) or trust fund (Form BMC-85). Bona fide agents do not need a bond under federal law.
- The 2023 document is interpretive guidance, not a new rule. Your actual facts decide your status.
What 88 FR 39368 is and why it exists
On Friday, June 16, 2023, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) published "Definitions of Broker and Bona Fide Agents" as a notification of final regulatory guidance. Its citation is 88 FR 39368 (Federal Register document 2023-13080), and it runs from page 39368 to 39373. You can read it on FederalRegister.gov or as the official PDF on GovInfo.
Congress ordered this guidance. The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act required FMCSA to examine the role of dispatch services, decide whether they could be brokers or bona fide agents, and clarify penalties for unauthorized brokerage under 49 U.S.C. 14916. The final version replaced interim guidance from November 16, 2022 (87 FR 68635), after FMCSA reopened the comment period on March 8, 2023.
The guidance covers six areas:
- The definition of broker
- The definition of bona fide agent
- The role of dispatch services
- How to tell whether a dispatch service is acting as a broker or a bona fide agent
- Services a dispatcher can provide without broker authority
- Services that require broker authority
It is interpretive guidance, not a new regulation, and the answer depends on the totality of the circumstances. FMCSA said it tried to describe "the maximum flexibility permissible under applicable law." Then-Administrator Robin Hutcheson said the guidance gives brokers, bona fide agents and dispatch services the information they need to make decisions for their operations.
Three definitions that decide everything
| Term | Source | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Broker | 49 U.S.C. 13102(2) | A person, other than a motor carrier or a carrier's employee or agent, who sells, offers for sale, negotiates for, or holds itself out as arranging motor carrier transportation for compensation |
| Broker | 49 CFR 371.2(a) | A person who arranges, or offers to arrange, transportation by an authorized motor carrier for compensation. FMCSA found this definition adequate. |
| Bona fide agent | 49 CFR 371.2(b) | Part of the carrier's normal organization, working under the carrier's direction under a preexisting agreement for a continuing relationship that rules out discretion in allocating traffic between the carrier and others |
| Dispatch service | None | No statutory, regulatory or commonly accepted definition exists |
That last row is the heart of the problem. Because "dispatch service" is not defined anywhere, FMCSA could not create a new type of operating authority for it through guidance. Instead, every dispatcher falls into an existing box: bona fide agent of a carrier, or broker. According to Benesch, FMCSA has no authority over dispatch services unless they also qualify as a broker, freight forwarder or motor carrier.
A few more points matter for independent dispatchers. A bona fide agent can be either an employee of the carrier or a contractor, but either way it must work under a preexisting agreement. A broker must get FMCSA authority; a bona fide agent does not. And the bona fide agent concept covers agents acting for a motor carrier, not brokers that use an agent model. FMCSA also said it cannot change the bona fide agent definition without a formal rulemaking.
The core test: who controls the work?
FMCSA says a dispatch service may be classified as either a broker or a bona fide agent depending on what it does and how much of it, and that deciding which requires a fact-specific analysis. No single factor settles the question. The biggest theme is control.
The greater the control, the less likely the 'dispatch service' needs broker authority.
FMCSA final guidance, as quoted by Trucking Info
Less carrier control suggests the dispatcher has more independent discretion over sourcing and allocating loads, and that looks more like brokerage. Representing more than one carrier does not automatically make you a broker, as Whitfield notes. But a dispatch service that arranges transportation for several carriers and allocates traffic among them "is not a bona fide agent and must obtain broker operating authority registration," as Overdrive reported.
FMCSA was candid about the business impact. It expects some dispatchers now working without authority may need to take on fewer carriers or apply for broker authority, and it acknowledged that dispatchers may not be able to run a successful business serving a single small carrier.
Factors pointing away from broker authority
In the final guidance, FMCSA reorganized its factors into two groups: those showing broker authority is not required and those showing it is required. Overdrive confirms the final version revised the nine "not required" factors from the interim guidance. Published analyses confirm these points:
- You are not an intermediary and are not involved in the money moving between the broker and the carrier.
- You provide services only to a carrier that has specifically appointed you as its agent.
- You go through a broker to arrange shipments and do not seek or solicit shippers. This appeared in the interim list, per Trucksafe; check the final wording.
- You are paid by the carrier under your contract, not by a broker or factoring company, per a secondary summary.
SafeCarriers boils the critical facts down to three questions: Is there a written agreement between the carrier and the dispatcher? Does the dispatcher work only in the carrier's interest? Does the carrier still handle negotiations and money with shippers?
Factors pointing toward broker authority
The second list describes conduct that crosses into brokerage. The clearest item in the official text says a dispatcher allocates traffic "by accepting a shipment that could be transported by more than one carrier with which it has agreements and assigns it to one of those carriers." Other warning signs from published analyses:
- Taking payment for a load from a broker or factoring company, or handling any part of the money between them.
- Negotiating directly with shippers.
- Assigning loads among several carriers.
- Splitting shipments between two or more carriers, which commenters on the interim guidance flagged as likely unauthorized brokerage.
On money, Transport Topics summarizes FMCSA's view: handling funds between shippers and carriers "strongly suggests the need for broker authority," but a person can be a broker without ever touching the money.
Secondary summaries differ slightly in wording and in how they count the "required" factors. Before you rely on any list, including ours, read both factor lists in the official Federal Register PDF. The same document addresses penalties for unauthorized brokerage under 49 U.S.C. 14916.
| Area | Points toward bona fide agent | Points toward broker |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship | The carrier specifically appointed you under a preexisting written agreement | No agreement, or you work loads for whoever calls |
| Money | The carrier pays you under your contract; you stay out of the payment flow | You take payment from a broker or factoring company or handle funds between parties |
| Load assignment | You have no discretion over which carrier gets a load | You accept a load several of your carriers could haul and pick one |
| Shippers | You work through brokers on the carrier's behalf | You negotiate directly with shippers |
| Control | The carrier directs your work | You decide sourcing and allocation on your own |
"Allocating traffic": the example that trips people up
FMCSA clarified that allocating traffic "means any exercise of discretion on an agent's part when assigning a load to a motor carrier." If an entity representing more than one carrier uses that discretion, it is not a bona fide agent. FMCSA's practical advice: "an agent representing multiple carriers should be careful to structure its agreements to avoid the possibility of allocating traffic."
FMCSA's examples of multi-carrier setups that do not involve allocation:
- Carrier clients that operate in different geographic regions.
- Hazardous materials loads for one carrier and general freight for another.
- Carriers that need different kinds of loads that do not overlap, as Overdrive describes.
And the example that does involve allocation: an independent dispatcher splitting loads between two separate one-truck dry van carriers running lanes in the same region. Overdrive describes that as brokering, which requires broker authority plus a $75,000 surety bond or trust. The logic is simple. When a load fits either truck, someone chooses which carrier gets it, and that choice is discretion.
If you are still deciding between a company dispatcher job and your own dispatch business, our truck dispatcher guide compares the two paths, and our dispatcher salary data shows what employed dispatchers earn.
If you need authority: the $75,000 bond or trust
Under 49 CFR 387.307, "a broker must have a surety bond or trust fund of $75,000 in effect," and FMCSA will not register a broker until the full amount is in place. A trust fund may hold only cash, irrevocable letters of credit from a federally insured depository institution, and Treasury bonds. Authority is suspended right away if the bond or trust falls below $75,000, according to eRegs. Freight forwarders need the same amount under 49 CFR 387.405.
Bona fide agents do not need a bond under federal law. FMCSA has also revised its broker financial responsibility rules; its docket page notes the revised §387.307 provisions were stayed until January 16, 2025. Check that page for current requirements before you apply.
Building a bona fide agent contract
If you want to stay on the agent side, your agreement with each carrier does much of the work. These steps follow 49 CFR 371.2(b), the guidance and published analyses. They are not a legal template.
- Sign before you startThe regulation requires a preexisting agreement that sets up a continuing relationship. Do not book a single load until it is signed.
- Define your role preciselyA written contract can spell out exactly what you do for the carrier. List each service and who makes final decisions.
- Rule out allocation discretionThe agreement must exclude discretion in allocating traffic between the carrier and others. If you serve more than one carrier, structure your book so loads cannot overlap, such as different regions or freight types.
- Keep money with the carrierGet paid by the carrier under your contract. Taking payments from brokers or factoring companies points toward brokerage.
- Show how you protect the carrierPrePass notes the contract should say how it protects the carrier's legal and financial interests.
- Review when your business changesAdding a carrier, a lane or an equipment type can create overlap. Recheck your setup each time.
When to talk to a transportation attorney
FMCSA does not tell dispatchers when to hire a lawyer. This section is our editorial advice based on how fact-specific the guidance is.
Because the answer depends on the totality of the circumstances, a short consultation with a transportation attorney is worth considering when:
- You plan to dispatch for two or more carriers with similar equipment or lanes.
- A carrier or broker asks you to collect payments or work with a factoring company.
- You want to find freight directly from shippers.
- You are drafting or signing your first carrier agreement.
- A course or "mentor" tells you dispatchers never need authority. The guidance says it depends.
Be wary of anyone selling dispatch training or "guaranteed" carrier clients with confident legal shortcuts. Our guide to spotting dispatcher job scams covers common red flags. For a broader view of the field, see our dispatcher careers overview.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need broker authority to dispatch for one owner-operator?
Generally not, if you act as that carrier's bona fide agent: appointed by the carrier, working under its direction under a preexisting agreement, and staying out of the money between broker and carrier. The facts of your setup still decide.
Can I dispatch for more than one carrier without broker authority?
Possibly. Representing more than one carrier is not automatically brokerage, but using discretion to allocate loads among them makes you a broker. FMCSA's non-allocation examples include carriers in different regions, or hazmat for one and general freight for another.
Is the 2023 guidance a new law?
No. It is interpretive guidance explaining existing statutes and regulations. FMCSA said it cannot change the bona fide agent definition without a rulemaking.
What financial requirement comes with broker authority?
A broker must have a $75,000 surety bond (Form BMC-84) or trust fund (Form BMC-85) in effect, and FMCSA will not register the broker until the full amount is in place. Check FMCSA for the other application requirements.
Does FMCSA regulate dispatch services directly?
Not unless a dispatch service also qualifies as a broker, freight forwarder or motor carrier. There is no separate dispatcher authority, and FMCSA said it cannot create one through guidance.
Sources
- Definitions of Broker and Bona Fide Agents (final guidance, June 16, 2023) — Federal Register
- 88 FR 39368 official PDF — U.S. Government Publishing Office
- Definitions of Broker and Bona Fide Agents (comment period reopened, March 8, 2023) — Federal Register
- 49 U.S.C. 13102 Definitions — Cornell Legal Information Institute
- 49 CFR 387.307 Property broker surety bond or trust fund — Cornell Legal Information Institute
- 49 CFR 387.307 — eRegs
- Broker and Freight Forwarder Financial Responsibility docket — FMCSA
- FMCSA's final guidance on broker authority for dispatchers — Overdrive
- FMCSA guidance on brokerage — Transport Topics
- FMCSA issues final guidance clarifying broker definition — Trucking Info
- FMCSA's final ruling on truck brokerage definitions now in effect — The Trucker
- New FMCSA guidance on dispatch services, bona fide agents and brokers — Benesch
- FMCSA brokers and bona fide agents — Whitfield
- FMCSA finalizes guidance on freight brokerage definitions — PrePass
- FMCSA clarifies key brokerage definitions — Trucksafe
